Best Shell Fuel Card Alternative in 2025

Shell fuel stations remain a common sight across Europe, reflecting the brand’s century-old presence and trusted fuel network. Shell’s fuel card has long been a go-to for fleet managers – and for good reason. Backed by one of the industry’s largest networks (over 46,000 Shell stations worldwide) and an electric charging footprint reaching ~800,000 charge points across Europe via roaming partners, Shell offers tremendous reach. Fleet operators trust the Shell brand for its reliability and appreciate its ongoing investments in EV infrastructure and sustainability. Shell’s card programs even provide fuel rebates (around 5 pence per litre off pump prices on Shell fuel, in some cases) to reward loyal volume. In short, Shell has built an enviable legacy of scale, convenience, and incentives in the fleet fuel card space.

However, fleet needs are evolving in 2025. Many procurement teams in Germany, France, Spain, and the UK are now exploring modern alternatives like Rally – not because Shell isn’t capable, but because the landscape is changing. From demands for total price transparency to the rise of electric vehicles, today’s fleets expect more than what traditional fuel cards have offered historically. In this post, we’ll put Shell head-to-head with Rally, a new open-loop fleet card, to see how they compare on the key factors: pricing, network coverage, EV support, and administrative control. We’ll also give an honest assessment of where Shell remains strong and where a solution like Rally might have the edge. Let’s dive in.

‍

What Modern Fleets Demand in 2025

Fleet managers across Europe are looking for solutions that meet the new realities of 2025. Here are the top priorities driving their search for Shell card alternatives:

• Transparent, fair pricing – no hidden markups: Gone are the days of accepting opaque “list prices.” Fleet operators want to pay pump prices or better, without unwelcome surprises. In markets like Germany, major fuel networks (including Shell) have used daily wholesale-based “list” prices that can run €0.20–€0.30 per liter higher than the price on the station totem. This lack of transparency has real costs – one analysis found a fleet in Germany was unknowingly paying €0.19/L above pump price with their old card. The UK’s regulators are similarly cracking down on hidden margins; the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) found supermarket fuel margins nearly doubled from 2019–2023 (costing drivers £1.6 billion in 2023) and prompted a new Fuel Finder scheme to enforce live price transparency by 2025. Simply put, fleets now demand honest, transparent pricing – they want to pay what’s on the pump, and see every fee upfront.

• Driver flexibility to access the cheapest stations: Fuel is a commodity, and price differences between stations can be huge – so fleets want cards that maximize their drivers’ freedom to fuel where it’s cheapest. Traditional closed-loop cards often have network restrictions that lock out big savings. In the UK, for example, supermarkets like Tesco and Asda sell ~44% of all fuel and tend to be 5–10 pence per liter cheaper than branded stations, yet many fuel cards either exclude supermarket forecourts or impose extra fees to use them. In France, hypermarket chains (e.g. E.Leclerc, Carrefour) account for 60% of fuel sales, with prices about €0.05–€0.10/L lower than those at oil company stations – but older card networks often can’t tap these outlets. Spain shows a similar trend: independent low-cost stations (BonÀrea, Plenoil, etc.) undercut major brands like Repsol by as much as €0.18/L (saving ~€9 on a 50L tank). And in Germany, highway fueling comes at a steep premium – Autobahn service plazas charge roughly €0.40 more per liter than stations just off the next exit. Fleet managers want their drivers to choose any station – whether it’s a supermarket, hypermarket, independent, or an off-highway stop – without network limits or penalties. Broad acceptance means better prices and less detouring, directly reducing fuel spend.

• Automation, control and digitization of admin: Fleet managers are also looking to save time and reduce human error in expense management. Traditional fuel cards often come with end-of-month surprises and laborious admin: paper receipts to chase, CSV reports to reconcile, and one-size-fits-all controls that are slow to adjust. Today’s fleets want real-time visibility of spending and the ability to set granular controls (e.g. per-driver or per-vehicle limits, allowed purchase categories, time-of-day usage rules) from an online dashboard. They also value innovative touches that streamline workflows – for instance, using messaging apps or mobile tools to engage drivers. A great example is Rally’s DriverLink feature, which lets drivers check in and activate a fuel card via a simple WhatsApp message, identifying themselves before fueling. Rally even uses WhatsApp to instantly collect odometer readings at each fill-up, dramatically improving mileage logging compliance. These kinds of conveniences, along with real-time alerts for suspicious transactions and automatic digital receipt capture, can save fleets dozens of hours in admin per month. (In fact, Rally users report ~18 hours saved each month on average by automating fuel expense tasks.) In 2025, a fuel card isn’t just a payment method – it’s part of the fleet management tech stack. Ease of use, data integration, and automation are key selling points.

In summary, fleet operators are looking for a fuel card that keeps up with the times: one that offers transparent pump pricing, universal acceptance (for fuel and charging), and modern controls with minimal overhead. With these criteria in mind, let’s examine how Shell’s fuel card stacks up against Rally’s fleet card on each of these dimensions.

‍

Shell vs. Rally: Feature Comparison Table

Here’s a side-by-side look at Shell’s fuel card versus the Rally fleet card on key features and criteria:

1. Fuel Pricing

Shell: Fixed wholesale-based pricing (weekly set price or oil “list” price) at many stations. Offers rebates up to ~5p/L for Shell fuel in some plans. However, pump prices at cheaper stations (supermarkets, independents) are often not accessible or not fully leveraged with the card. List price model can result in paying above displayed pump price in exchange for later rebates.

Rally: Actual pump price billing at every station – you always pay the price on the pump, with no markups or hidden surcharges. No complex rebate schemes needed; savings come directly from using the lowest-cost stations and avoiding extra fees. What you see is what you pay, every time.

2. Network Coverage

Shell: ~24,600 fuel sites across Europe (≈8,800 Shell-branded + 15,800 partner stations) in 33 countries. Strong coverage on highways and in cities; accepted at major oil brands and some supermarkets (e.g. Shell card covers Morrisons in UK). Network exclusions: Some low-cost chains and hypermarkets are out of network, meaning the card may not work or incurs fees there. Overall, very wide coverage but not truly 100%.

Rally: Universal acceptance at 100% of stations that take card payments – effectively every petrol station or truck stop in Europe that accepts Visa/Mastercard. This includes all big brands, independent stations, supermarket forecourts, etc. No need to plan routes around specific networks – drivers have complete freedom to refuel wherever convenient (or cheapest) without network restrictions.

3. EV Charging

Shell: Integrated Shell Recharge network with roaming access to ~800k charge points Europe-wide. Shell card doubles as an EV charging card via Shell Recharge/NewMotion – enabling charging at countless public stations with one account. Potential discounted rates on Shell’s own chargers for cardholders. EV charging sessions appear on the same invoice. Excellent coverage of charging infrastructure (around 80% of public chargers via partners).

Rally: Open payment EV charging – use the Rally card at any charging station that supports credit card or app payments. No dedicated charging network, but as of 2024 new EU rules mandate card readers on public fast chargers, making Rally broadly compatible. Charging costs are simply billed as transactions on the card. While Rally lacks Shell’s roaming platform, it provides flexibility to charge anywhere (with a standard payment method) and consolidates those expenses in real time on the fleet dashboard.

4. Controls & Security

Shell: Standard controls via Shell Fleet Hub: set product restrictions (fuel only, no shop), spending limits, and require PIN for driver ID. Reporting tools (e.g. ClearView analytics) highlight anomalies and fuel efficiency after the fact. Card can be deactivated if lost (typically via call or portal). Security is solid (Shell is an experienced provider) but not instantaneous – changes or fraud alerts may not be real-time. Drivers often share cards/PINs due to legacy workflow (less personalized control).

Rally: Real-time, customizable controls through Rally’s software: fine-tune spend limits per day or per transaction, restrict usage to certain times or geographies, and block specific merchant categories or even individual merchants. Instant card freeze/unfreeze at your fingertips. Advanced security with live fraud detection – get instant alerts for suspicious transactions and block them on the spot. Each driver can be linked to a card via WhatsApp (DriverLink) for accountability. Overall, a very granular and proactive control environment, minimizing misuse and fraud in real time.

5. Admin & Reporting

Shell: Detailed invoices and tax compliance – Shell provides consolidated invoicing compliant with tax authorities (simplifying VAT reclaim). Web portal offers transaction reports, but data may update after a delay (daily or so). Some plans have fees (e.g. certain Shell cards charge a small monthly fee per card or transaction fees at specific sites). Admin work needed to reconcile if using multiple networks or when exceptions occur (e.g. using a non-network station). Customer support is available but can be slower via call centers.

Rally: Automated admin & real-time data – Every transaction appears instantly in the Rally dashboard with full details. No card fees, no per-transaction fees – simple transparent billing. Receipts can be captured via a quick photo (even through WhatsApp) and automatically matched to transactions, greatly reducing manual reconciliation work. Customizable reports and integrations (export data or sync with accounting systems) are built in. Rally’s support team is 24/7 and responds within minutes, providing quick help whenever needed. Overall, fleets save significant admin hours with Rally’s streamlined approach.

‍

Conclusion: Shell’s Strengths vs. Rally’s Edge

Both Shell and Rally offer compelling fleet card solutions, but they excel in different areas. Shell’s fuel card leverages the power of a globally recognized brand and infrastructure: an enormous fuel station network, and time-tested account management practices. For fleets that value Shell’s brand trust, broad station coverage, and fuel rebate programs, the Shell card remains a strong, reliable choice. It particularly shines for enterprises that already partner with Shell for fuel supply or those that require the assurance of Shell’s dedicated truck stops and services on major routes. In short, Shell brings size, stability, and a one-stop solution for fuel, backed by decades of industry experience.

Rally’s fleet card, on the other hand, represents the new wave of fleet fintech – prioritizing transparency, flexibility and tech-driven control. Rally tends to outperform when it comes to cost transparency and savings: by eliminating price markups and allowing access to cheaper fuel sources (like supermarkets or independents), it often delivers lower net fuel costs without the need for complex rebate schemes. Fleet managers who have felt frustration with the lack of clarity in fuel pricing will find Rally’s straightforward pump-price billing refreshing. Additionally, Rally offers unparalleled acceptance and convenience – drivers have the freedom to use any station or charger, an important edge in countries like France or Spain where low-cost retailers dominate and in the UK/Germany where price variation is high. The platform’s real-time controls and automation are also a game-changer for many modern fleets; features like WhatsApp-based driver authentication and instant spend alerts simply didn’t exist in the fuel card world until now. For a busy fleet manager trying to reduce administrative headaches and tighten control on expenses, Rally provides tools to do so with minimal effort, potentially saving hours and euros every month.

In an honest assessment, Shell is still the leader in terms of sheer network services and integrated energy solutions – if a fleet values extensive fueling amenities, established processes, and perhaps fuel volume discount arrangements, Shell’s offering is very robust. It’s also a known quantity; there’s comfort in the legacy. Yet, Rally has the edge in agility and user-centric design – it turns a fleet card from a static payment tool into a dynamic expense management system. For fleets in 2025 that are chasing efficiency, cost reduction, and digital transformation of their operations, a solution like Rally can drive tangible improvements (often reported as 5–10% fuel cost savings and double-digit hour reductions in admin time).

Ultimately, the “best Shell fuel card alternative” will depend on your fleet’s priorities. If you’re looking to modernize and want a card that gives you full pricing transparency, universal acceptance (fuel & EV), and real-time control, Rally is a very strong contender to consider. Many fleets have already made the switch and seen benefits in both cost and convenience. On the other hand, if you highly value the brand reliability, perks, and coverage that Shell provides, you might even choose to use both – maintaining Shell for its network strengths while introducing Rally to tap into new savings where Shell’s card has limitations.

For fleet managers and procurement teams in Germany, France, Spain, the UK and beyond, the key is to evaluate which solution aligns better with your 2025 goals – lower fuel spend, better data, less admin, EV readiness, and driver satisfaction. The good news is that you have options. Shell’s card is no longer the only game in town for a comprehensive fleet solution. Rally and other fintech innovations are pushing the industry forward, and that competition only helps fleets get more value.

If you’re curious to learn more about how Rally works in practice and what a switch could mean for your fleet’s bottom line, feel free to reach out for a demo or consultation. The landscape of fleet fuel cards is changing – and your fleet stands to benefit from the new choices available. Here’s to smarter fueling and charging in 2025 and beyond!